9mm vs bear. The more than century-old debate of .

• 9mm vs bear The 9mm exemplifies everything I heard a first hand account of a 9mm used in defense during a black bear attack. Is a 9mm handgun effective against bears? A 9mm handgun may not have enough stopping power to effectively take down a bear. 9×19. 357 and . Instead, it fires a 0. You want and need penetration. Here’s a breakdown of the 9mm vs 40 S&S in terms of terminal ballistics: Richard Mann. Here are some thoughts on whether you should carry bear spray or a firearm as protection. Training and preparation are crucial in effectively defending against a bear attack, both in terms of firearm proficiency and following proper protocols for bear encounters. Some of the lighter loads will be very manageable, but ammo is about twice as expensive for 10mm vs 9mm, if not more. There is you answer a 9mm is not bringing down a 9′ brown bear with a single round. s. Brown bear shot by policemen s after attack on veterinarian,police uses that time (2010) 9mm Makarov, I'm pretty sure about 95% it was basic FMJ (Full metal Of the rounds you mentioned I'd recommend critical duty +P. 38 vs 9mm For concealed carry purposes, there aren't too many reasons to choose 38 vs 9mm. 357 Magnum revolver holstered on the right side of my binocular harness, resting against my ribs. When the M ° pÆÇ0íPS Ï×r ùw ¶1¦ v%4û´¾:Ü"ôfç \,‡Pq§ÌËÞV 24˜ f}Ò%s—*ÿ^ØT òÈ êom_§BŒ Ëý"vÝ| WBÎóØ·(" œ§@ÌU ¢K¿ø´³ Ç Generally speaking, 9 mm pistols are constructed with barrels somewhere between 3" to 5" in length. 45 ACP” articles and videos suggests that everyday gun owners haven’t made up their minds. If you want to start handgun hunting or want something with a little extra juice for bear defense, the 10mm Auto and the . So in summary, the bear-vs-man scenario does raise very real social Stalking a black bear, got withing 30yards made a good shot and the bear spun and charged full speed at us On this episode of Ultimate Barrier Testing, we will be comparing the performance of the 9mm Luger to the 45 ACP on 4 different targets. 357/9mm LCR frames are aluminum, so a strength issues arises along with each cylinder needing to be timed for that particular gun. penetration and expansion) than the 9mm Luger, as well as better external ballistics (i. Im going to get a Sig 2022 in either . In a study done in 2008 (Smith et. Grain for grain and inch by inch (or mm by mm), the 9mm is a much smaller projectile than the 45 ACP is. Mature bears weigh anywhere from 150 pounds to over 1000 based on species and geographical location. (At a difference of, say, $0. Both calibers demonstrated formidable penetration capabilities, with the 9mm and 10mm rounds making their way through extensive lengths of gelatin and even It has been used successfully against bears and wild boar and is truly effective. A . Dogs assisted in 2 incidents, buying time for the owner to fire. The Deutsche Waffen-und Munitionsfabriken, a company that had me If you can manage it carry . As a medium sized handgun the 9mm would be a good choice of caliber when carrying to defend yourself against black bears. Now anything over 250lbs is a "big bear". Although there’s only a difference of one millimeter between these two cartridges on paper, the actual story on the ground is immensely different. 44 Magnum or . The 9x19mm cartridge is also referred to as the NATO Recovering a bear with #waltherpdp https://www. 9mm +P ammo is a variant of the standard 9mm cartridge that has been loaded to a higher internal pressure. 9mm vs The 275 and 280lb. These calibers offer In short, 9mm pistols represent the very bottom rung of the bear defense handgun caliber ladder. 357 9×18mm Makarov (9mm Makarov) Shop Silver Bear Ammo. Interestingly enough the only handgun round I could find that failed to end an Can you use a 9mm to kill a bear? Read our fact-based article to learn everything you want to know about bear defense! Firstly, and most surprisingly to yours truly, there were four cases in which the 9mm cartridge was used to defend against bears — every single one of them was successful, and at least three of the four were against grizzly bears. I know this argues against prevailing wisdom, but the prevailing wisdom is based mostly on speculation, not real-world experience, and is not really wisdom. One good one can save Does 10mm vs 9mm have any sort of practical ramifications? 10mm vs 9mm For Self-Defense When it comes to 10mm vs 9mm for self-defense, 9mm pretty much wins. While I was totally confident in its abilities to stop a bear, Accordingly, I’m hedging my bets by selecting an alternative bear-defense load, the Hornady 9mm +P 115-grain, MonoFlex Handgun Hunter solid-copper hollowpoint. This comparison will test the elegance of the 9mm against the destructive hard-hitting power of the 10mm Auto which has now established itself as a popular bear defense and even self-defense gun. 45 acp is a poor choice for bear defense. 56 meets only one criterion. It might be a little small when taking on a grizzly but would still do a good job. The 10mm was created to exhibit better terminal ballistics (i. 992 to . Bears too have minimum energy levels the bullets have to impart to them. When In this article we’ll explore whether a 9mm can kill a bear, discuss the pros and cons of various calibers used for defense against bears, and help you decide which type of gun best fits your 9mm firearms can be effective against bears if proper shot placement and ammunition selection is considered. A. You can’t hide the fact that both the 9mm and . 45 chambered 1911s, the same considerations we mentioned in the prior sections apply as well. I saw two shots go in its mouth, i saw the eye pop. You forgot consider weight during the hike, and getting the weapon to fire position with little to no warning. 9mm is seriously under your need, 357 Mag in a hot hard cast would be the absolute minimum I would consider. Until now, I have never had to shoot an unwounded bear to protect either myself or clients, but the other week an event occurred and my good fortune I looked up the size of black Bears, and it says the average size in the Smokey Mountains is 250ish lbs. So, I just got into an argument with a Canadian over firearms and there ability to kill bears. All brown bears share a large build, a dish-shaped face, and a shoulder hump. 223 round may not reliably penetrate a bear’s skull, potentially resulting in a non-fatal shot. The difference between 9mm Makarov and 9mm Luger is that the 9mm Luger has a higher case capacity and is superior to the Makarov round in all ballistic categories. BUT, if you're hunting in grizzly country year after year, the head at point blank with a fmj. 45 and 9mm's bullets; Both cartridges can be designed to deliver more tha a foot of penetration in a human body As more people participate in outdoor activities, contact between bears and people has increased. 38 Special+P in 'full size' and 'short barrel' handguns. 365” (9. Best 9mm Ammunition vs. 9mm Stopping Power. Chuke tests some Grizzly 9mm +p+ 147 grain Kodiak Match Bear Loads vs a saber tooth tiger resin skull in order to emulate a tactical situation vs a bear skul With a 9mm, he likely applied a decent field of fire onto the bear at center mass and one of the rounds proved enough to bring the beast down. 38 Special rounds. What is the effective range for bear Winner: 9mm Luger. Winner: The 40 S&W may technically has a slight advantage, but for all practical purposes, it’s a tie. The store will not work correctly when cookies are disabled. The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: General Handgun Forum: 9mm VS. 4. Most people imagine a bear charging, and the measure of success is whether the bear folds to the ground, sliding up to their feet or not. 095-inch difference between . This is But up against an angry bear, I'd rather be armed with a 45-70 than EITHER a 22-250 or a 10mm loaded with lightweight "Magic" bullets that make impressive "wound channels Whereas a shot from a 9mm might theoretically only slow down a threat, the same exact shot from a 10mm could neutralize it instantly. Links:-Phil's Outfitter Service: https://grizzlyskinsofalaska. The Super demonstrated a 6-percent advantage in velocity and a 13-percent advantage in kinetic energy. 223 Rem; 6. " With a 9mm that is essentially what you'd be doing. Outdoorsmen, hunters, and enthusiasts must always exercise extreme caution. 380’s. 45 Colt. To illustrate the point. To me, if a black bear comes after me, it is totally my fault due to not being bear-safe. Brown Bear Handguns: General Handgun Forum. The Stats . S. Far from it, in fact. 56 will also work for To start, I have to establish that there is a difference between the 9mm Luger vs. While not bullet proof, bears can take enormous punishment and still live long enough to end you. The 9mm gets a majority of its “stopping power” in the form of having a lot of little friends that have accompanied it inside the magazine. Some of the popular 9mm ammunition options for bear defense include Buffalo Bore 9mm +P Outdoorsman, Federal Premium Personal Defense 9mm 124 grain, and Speer Minimum caliber is 4x against bear. This isn’t the first time that a 45 bagged a big one. 45 ACP by three years Georg Luger finalized his design and brought it out in 1902, pairing it with the Luger pistol. 5×39mm Grendel; 6. 28286 posts · Joined 2017 Add to quote; Only show this user #8 . 500 S&W, it’s just punching holes. 61×51mm. 45 Auto are two popular options. 'Nough said. 9mm +P Ammo vs Regular 9mm Ammo As with all things in the firearm world, costs have to be a consideration. Even the largest and seemingly ungainly bear can run you down at speeds approaching 35 mph, and if your response isn’t adequate, the In fact, I can tell you from my experience that 45 ACP is not so perfect compared to other popular ammunition like 9mm, 357 Magnum. I’ll admit it: The pistol makes me feel more comfortable, as though I could meet deadly force with Bears are generally not prone to attack humans. Bear Creek Arsenal Grizzly 101 9mm Review. For the most part, I carry (usually) a 9mm something something, but if I had to choose between a 9mm or . July 26, 2024. 45 ACPs against bears, shooting it at least five times before it created enough damage to kill or hurt the bear. All were successful [] This just reminds me that most handgun failures against bears aren't reported. Can a 9mm hollow point stop a bear? While a 9mm hollow point can be effective for self-defense, it may not provide enough penetration and stopping power against a bear. 45 is what I shoot most but it’s definitely not something I would choose against a bear. Because of their size and the adrenaline, A 9mm is fine really, you're dealing with black bears not polar bears or kodiaks. 9mm and bear spray. With the right 357, I can achieve upwards of 1800fps in a 16” barrel. americanhun DISCLAIMER: ALL INDIVIDUALS WERE LEGAL ADULTS AT THE TIME OF THIS VIDEO AND ALL SAFETY GUIDELINES WERE FOLLOWED. ly/2UEAkgWUR on Patreon: https://www. In the great bear-gun debate—10mm vs . 45ACP vs 9mm rages on. In addition, there is a story on the 9mm Outdoorsman page of an Alaskan guide that killed a large charging grizz with these bullets. Prior to the 1990s, or you need a powerful pistol for protection in bear country, then 10mm loaded to full power actually is an attractive option. the 9mm ammo comparison, there is a stark difference. 9mm seems to perform well against bear, regardless of the particular bullet used - Update of Pistol or Handgun Defenses Against Bears - AmmoLand. My 10mm vs. Avoid the temptation to There are some reports and news about people using . Watch and see what we Discover!Check out ou The . With good shot placement, you’re just as well off with a nine. On 9mm vs 10mm if you feel like you need to carry, The best use for a gun against a bear is as a noise maker, For which there are plenty of alternatives. Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www. Heck, get a . The hard cast bullets are less likely to deviate on impact or shatter, While a 9mm may not be the ideal choice for bear defense, understanding its limitations and effectiveness can increase your chances of survival in a close encounter. 850 hiked efficiency and suited it to existing 9mm frames and slides. Each target is worth. A Bear. 45 ACP vs. com/channel/UC-XmXuLLaC_4h0ZOOz5WbVA/joinPat The 9mm cartridge was invented by German Georg Luger in 1901 for the British Small Arms Committee and caught some eyes at Springfield Arsenal in 1903. For target shooting, the 9mm Luger is probably better if price is a concern. 27mm) bullet diameter round. Find what works for your needs in this full comparison. Reliably and instantly incapacitating a bear—stopping a charge—with center-of-bear shots with anything less than a . com (Edited to add photo of . Alaska, Russian River, Grizzly Charged Fishermen, 9mm 17 August, Hard-cast is preferred over FMJ. 308 would be recommended against brown bears. ) It might maybe in an off chance suffice against black bears maybe but definitely not against brown bears. All of the below I base on factory ammo offerings and not handloads: 10mm is the most versatile- the loads range from super light hyper velocity at about 100gr all the way up to dangerous game loads of 220-230gr. 62x39, 9mm vs bear? I am not asking if this is a viable cartridge to hunt bear. —which camp are you in? Without question there’s been a major shift from the . 45 caliber Devel Radially Dynamic bullet) I'm thinking if the 9mm can kill a bear as mentioned, then my 45ACP with the BB 45ACP 255 grain +P Hardcast FN should be just as good if not better. Michael. However, the 9mm is the most common pistol caliber in the world. 5. 22 and . 56 Compared to 9mm. 9mm is suitable for the more likely danger which are trespassers/poachers and feral dog packs. As a geologist, Nelson has killed four bears in defense of life and property (DLP), including two Grizzly bear attacks Jimmy Cox; downed at 10 feet with a 10mm pistol in Defense of Life and Property Incident in AK. Personally I'm in the 9mm camp in Black bear We have found four cases where 9 mm pistols were used to defend against bears. Phil Shoemaker & Buffalo Bore. The 9mm is a mid-power handgun cartridge that can kill bears, but it may not stop them quickly enough. It may surprise you. 45 ACP 1911s have higher recoil and anywhere from a 7- to 8-round Live in a similar area and though I take my 44 out when the bears are most active, I usually run my 9mm for most camping/hiking trips. In this episode of TFBTV, James discusses whether or not carrying a large caliber handgun is a good idea for defending the person against large predators (in Conversely, a 9mm hardcast will still be effective against any attacker; although it may perform less well against humans and other small things than HP, I’d have no hesitation about smoking a 500lb guy with a 9mm hollow point, Most folks think that bear defense revolves around one age-old debate: pistol versus bear spray. The 9mm would later on be adopted by the German Navy in 1904 and caught widespread affection from the German military in 1908. fortscottmunitions. Improvements are across the board however and all cartridges have benefited, In total, there were 8 defenses against black bears and 27 defenses against grizzly bears. However, I wouldn't take a 9mm into a bear fight, 10mm would be the smallest I'd trust. al. W. I have been guiding brown bear hunters and fishermen and bear photographers from our homestead within Becharof National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska for 33 years and have had numerous close encounters with bears. (at least one was a 9mm - not much help there), and the hollowpoints stopped before hitting anything important. Both our side charging and rear charging 9mm upper selections are compatible with 9mm lowers and come with a bolt carrier group and charging handle so you can be ready to shoot right out of the box. 243 Winchester; 9mm 115 gr Federal FMJ vs 124 gr Federal Hydrashok, Top That’s not to say that FMJ rounds are useless for defense. Follow the 4-3-1 rule. It certainly wouldn't be my top choice against grizzly/brown bears. 5 incidents were initiated by dog(s). You are talking service calibers which have spotty records against 200# human Chuke experiments with Underwood Extreme Penetrator in 9mm with his actual bear head (skinned with brain in) to see if a 9mm is really capable of killing a Bill in Tennessee calls the Gun Talk After Show to see if the Buffalo Bore hard cast 9mm load would be good enough for defense against coyotes and bears whil In the wild, adventurous terrains of the West and Alaska, venturing into bear territory is almost inevitable. “I am a big fan of the 10mm for a bear defense handgun, but there are some premises that need to be understood. 45 Auto +P Xtreme Penetrators Verses the I wouldn't do it. 44 Is the 9mm with thoughtful bullet selection enough stop a charging grizzly bear? Some say yes, some say no. Yes, a 9mm at 20 feet with a direct head If there was any doubt that a 9 mm pistol could protect you against a grizzly bear, a long-time fishing and hunting guide has a shocking story to tell. After 33 years guiding in the Becharof National Wildlife Refuge, Phil Shoemaker shot I'm going crazy, but this is the science behind it. The store That’s why folks use it for hunting and defense against tooth-and-claw critters like bears. com/ultimatereloaderUR T-Shirts: https://bit. But all have been effective against bears, contrary to the claim you need to have nothing less than a rifle. +P to give it a bit more ass behind it and critical duty tends to penetrate a lot (like in human targets over penetrate constantly. 357 Magnum vs. Can a . Can a 9mm be effective with proper shot placement? A 9mm can be effective with proper shot placement, but it may not have enough stopping power to quickly incapacitate a grizzly bear. 45 is more suited for the task. 9. Several It's about stopping the bear in close, where you may only get 1-2 shots. 357 Mag wheel gun. 22lr vs brown bear: news article, plenty of other cases with Alaskan natives hunting bear with 22lr. Shot placement is everything. chukesoutdoor. The smallest bear took 4 shots, 3 in the lungs thast turned the The 22 vs. It would be impossible to replicate a surprise bear charge, so this is probably as close as we can get other than studying after action reviews of real bear charges. In this review, we’ll reopen an age-old debate to find any distinguishing performance factors between the very popular 9mm and . Of course there was a preconclusion of the research- it would prove guns are worthless against bears and only pepper spray stops Our 9mm uppers make great options for self-defense, target shooting, and provide the ability to shoot cheap and widely available ammunition. Non . 9mm vs 45. 40 are ALMOST identical when it comes to ballistics bigger and faster is better. 11. If you prefer to carry a 9mm pistol, or it’s your only option, the best overall cartridge is the Buffalo Bore 147 grain. Build up your expectations for the availability of ammo/guns, and the economics associated with it. Go back 100 years and 9mm would be considered rifle velocities. You can find Glock 9mm magazines everywhere (the assumption Several people have survived bear attacks because the bear had suffered a broken jaw/teeth and was unable to normally bite. Modern 9mm defensive ammunition is superb, and the differences in the terminal performance of 9mm vs 10mm aren’t terribly far apart. Encounter high performance at a low Even a good heavy-caliber, knock-him-down lung or heart shot may not keep a bear from getting back up and running off. 07 per round, that’s $140 after 2,000 shots. That only stands to reason, given the effectiveness of modern 9mm ammo, and its availability in 19 rounds of 9mm at a bear seems like a better candidate to me than a . The 9mm Luger might be the king of modern handgun cartridges, but it’s far from the most powerful. 22 to practice with if you're inexperienced. 62×25 vs 9mm: Costs, Availability, & Compatibility. American gun enthusiasts have been debating the comparative merits of the 9mm Luger and the . ݺ> k>*‰À`p{ b$*•Mø «¼¢ž‚ R‘lr 2¸È2w‹Aë&îÌgp ‘B# V(YI{( A ‹Â L/ q £¶Ns _í&ü| 28˲ÑXL Æ KJC p{ º To read our full review of 40 S&W vs 45 ACP CLICK HERE. Typically for bears you'd want to carry 10mm hard-cast rounds, 180-220gr. black bear, . Somebody took down a Kodiak at Denali a few years ago with a 45. When comparing 9mm and . You can get compact 9mm pistols like 5. Training and preparation are crucial in effectively defending against a bear attack, both in terms of firearm proficiency Compare the effectiveness of 9mm pistol caliber against black bears, considering kinetic energy, bullet design, anatomy, and real-life encounters to ensure a successful hunt. In light of this, it makes sense to lean toward penetration which insures straight line wounds to reach vitals and, hopefully, the central nervous system. The 5. grizzly bear, . We don't really let bears get that big anymore anyway. The 9mm+P is a 147 gr hard cast flat nose r It can be nearly all things to all men. Brown bears forage on roots, berries, insects, and fish, and some even hunt young mammals such as elk and moose. 45 acp with modern +P ammo and hardened bullets for bear defense. There is only a fingernail or two difference between a 9mm and a 45 ACP. 15 rounds of 10mm Dangerous Game loads are better than 6-7 rounds of 357mag DG loads, and that's why Greenland's Sirius Sledge Patrol uses Glock In general, the . When wielding a 9mm v. Although trajectory may not be as important for pistol ammunition as rifle cartridges, it can still make a If an extra dollar per round means you get to come home from the woods safe with a wildly victorious man vs. It is accurate, has low recoil, and is chambered in many firearms. bears, the old adage about 'age and treachery' comes to mind. This debate has only been exacerbated when the U. ” Canada Black Bear gets DROPPED with our 9MM TUI™! AUTOPSY INCLUDED AT THE END OF THE VIDEO - VIEWER DISCRETION IS ADVISEDWebsitewww. Firing a 115-grain bullet at 1200 f. a 45 loaded with +p has more energy then a 9mm +p, so that it what I would take 9mm is a more efficient round for its size and has much greater capacity but unless you are being attacked by a posse of hogs or bears that would matter very little Chuke tests Extreme Penetrator and various hollow points on a meat sack meant to simulate grizzly bear flesh. A handgun is better than nothing, but whether it’s a 9mm or . 2008), researchers analyzed 83 bear spray incidents (61 brown bears, 20 black bears and two polar bear). As a result, I got to looking around at 9mm ammo and ran across the Buffalo Bore +P outdoorsman rounds. 44 Remington Magnum and other fire-belching revolvers toward semiautos chambered in 10mm Auto for those wanting a measure of personal protection against bruins and other potentially dangerous animals. For most people the 9mm will be a better choice for EDC self defense, but the extra power of the 10mm is certainly worth considering. 22 caliber pistol enough for bear protection? A . Is the 10mm a better option? The hosts, Ryan and Mark, embarked on a journey to determine the adequacy of 9mm and 10mm handguns for bear defense through a range of drills that mimicked potential When choosing a pistol caliber for protection against bears, it’s recommended to use a larger, more powerful round such as . There are numerous ways to improve your safety in bear country. 22lr vs. Think bears, boars, and xenomorphs. At the same time, most 9mm pistols have larger magazines and offer the shooter the ability to take multiple rapid follow-up shots. A 9mm would Is a 9mm effective against a bear? While a 9mm may be effective for self-defense, it is not recommended for taking down a bear due to its limited stopping power. And if you use a 9mm on a bear and injure it, you will have a lot of 'splaining to do to the game warden. Forget any handgun. It bled 2. Shot placement is crucial when using a 9mm against a grizzly bear, aiming for vital areas such as the brain or the heart. Accuracy. com-American Hunter article: https://www. Conscious of her flesh being shredded and “teeth against bone,” she heard the canines “crunching on my skull. However, an upgrade to a Glock 20 chambered in 10mm and loaded with hard-cast FNs will provide far more stopping power than the Cartridge Talks, in its latest episode, "9mm vs 10mm – Best for Bear Defense?" aims to shed light on an important question: in a grizzly situation, is the formidable power of the 10mm We were taught that the Brown bear and the Kodiak bear were the same species, and the dividing line was a coastal mountain range in Alaska. Apparently these hard cast rounds are extremely reliable and accurate according to the manufacturer. But there is also a big difference between a Brown bear and a blackie. K. These are big beasts, and ornery, too. In this case, Phil was using 147gr hard cast bullets made by Buffalo Bore that are designed specifically for deep penetration, which mitigates some of the risk of using a 9mm against a bear. That faster moving heavier bullet is going deeper and Can a . 44 Mag. Accuracy depends on many factors, including the gun, T he 9mm vs 45 ACP argument has been going on for more than a century. I love my glock 20 but if you are really anti glock the Sig xten is another decent choice. If you want semi auto, Underwood sells 10mm ammo that is on par with 357. 9mm +p with hard penetrator bullets would be adequate if you couldn’t get your hands on something bigger. If no grizz in the area, I carry my Glock 43 with XTPs. effective range and So in reality a bear in the woods is probably more like 10,000+ times more likely to kill a woman than a man would be. If you really want something bigger you can get a 10mm or a . Used to be some real man eating monster size bears 200+ years ago. The stopping power of a round describes its ability to decimate a target as quickly as Can a 9mm kill a bear? Yes, a 9mm would kill a bear. In March 2012, the Journal of Wildlife Management When that bear comes, it sounds like a huffing, puffing, forest wrecking freight train. One pistol failure out of 35 cases translates to a 97% success rate for the use of handguns against bears. ) Yes, a 9mm bullet is plenty strong enough to penetrate a Black Bears skin, ribcage, and then rupture internal organs. A recent episode of “Cartridge Talks” aimed to shed light on this [] 9mm firearms can be effective against bears if proper shot placement and ammunition selection is considered. 21 a Round FREE S&H Options, (Limit 1) >seven cases where 9 mm pistols were used to defend against bears. I had previously tested, compared and proven such loads with my . 22 kill a But only bears indigenous to the northeast so mainly black bears. They have hard cast lead round around 700 lbs of energy. Learn the main differences between 9mm vs 10mm ammo and what each is used for. bears went down quickly, not one shot drops, but neither of them went more than 50ft. When the bear approached, the bowhunter climbed a tree but the bear followed. on 12/20/2017 02:35pm. This is my For rifle defense against black bears and cougars I’d go with the Federal Fusion 150gr. 45 acp yea unless its a koala bear id go with something bigger and im not just hatin on 9mm its definitely one of my favorite calibers but for something like bear id absolutely go with something beefier What other factors should be considered when using a . 223 penetrate a bear skull? A . 9mm Luger vs 45 ACP is perhaps the quintessential handgun caliber debate that has been raging since World War II. Those who carry a 9mm for bears load up with heavy fmj or hardcast ammo. A big one. Sure the hardcast ammo makes a difference. 9x19mm, 9mm Parabellum, or 9x19mm automatic. 9mm vs 45 ACP; 9mm vs 40 S&W. Two types of bears occur commonly in numerous states of the US and Canada, the Brown and Black Bears. When it comes to recognizing and responding to a bear attack, few people have as much experience as Alaska’s Steve Nelson, a former research geologist for the U. The critical question of whether to carry a 9mm or a 10mm Still, in its full-size configuration, the Erector is one of the quieter 9mm silencers available. I feel much better carrying my 45 as a woods gun when it's loaded with Buffalo Bore. By popular request, we take on the topic of using handguns for self-defense against bear attacks, drawing on 162 documented cases collected by Ammoland. 357 bullets from In general, standard armament for the man on watch vs bears is a 12ga shotgun loaded with solid slugs. While I AM in Grizz country ( 30 mins from Glacier National Park ) I have no intentions of using a handgun against a bear. I personally know one bowhunter who was treed by Back from shooting 9mm and 10mm pistols at charging paper targets, ballistic gel blocks, and bear skulls, Back from shooting 9mm and 10mm pistols at charging paper The ongoing debate between 9mm vs 10mm handgun cartridges oft. We all know that the caliber wars are stoopid. Handguns, in general, are poor tools for stopping a bear charge. The difference in the energy characteristics for these rounds is not too much, especially beyond 50 yards. If there would be one single “representative” load for each of these cartridges, it A 9mm simply does not have the energy to penetrate through thick bear skulls and bones consistently and you will need ideal shot placement to survive a bear attack with a 9mm. What is the minimum caliber for I'm not about to give a warning shot with bear spray, but I love having it as a backup to the loud sound of a warning shot fired in the ground (always in the ground!) in the bear's direction - I strongly believe (from personal anecdotal experience) that bear spray is more likely to keep you alive in the event of a true charge (not bluff charge, which can be hard to tell in the moment, Bear Spray vs. Reply. In general, the . I don’t think they are tough animals. 357 or 10mm would be much better though, especially with the right ammunition. 45 ACP since the first U. a Bear By Bridget Fabel #Survival 01-07-24. The round is slow, fat, and has fairly poor penetration on tough-skinned animals; however, some people carry . Guns: What New Science Says. It can be used for hunting in some SIG loads the Super with a 125-grain V-Crown bullet and the 9 mm with a 124-grain V-Crown. 9mm trajectory contest is easily won by the 22, but it's most often shot from a rifle, so we expected this outcome. I’d still carry the 9mm while you’re out there if it’s your largest caliber handgun. HP ammo is for humans, for bear, think hard cast. The 10mm round is the clear bear cartridge of choice if you are going to use a semi-auto handgun. Not unlike choosing a SD round against a 2 legged attacker. Handguns have been shown to be effective tools when used to defend against bears. You make a good argument, intelligently explained about the 9mm versus 40 S. 6 fatal bear attacks in the United States per year. Trail Guns: 9mm vs. (or a 124 around 1100), the 9mm was always “zippier” than the A Bear Defense Handgun Worked If the Attack is Stopped. 4x caliber and up 300 grain and up At least 1000 FPS Your 5. I said that you could kill a bear with a 9mm pistol. https://www. Even though there are bears in my area they are still rare and I usually only catch 1 or 2 on the trail cameras a year. Polar bears are the exception. You can find it at every corner of the globe. 40 is adequate for use against black bears, the 9mm should not be depended on for use against bears. Their hair is lighter at the tips, which led to the name of the most famous subspecies, grizzly. Full Story: http://bit. However it would not stop a Black bear dead in its tracks. There are practical ways to avoid bear interactions. 40 just because it’s a bigger round and hotter load. Winchester USA 9mm 115Gr FMJ Ammunition $0. This is particularly the case regarding ammo purchase. a Mountain Lion Boone & Crocket bear skulls, ballistics gel, pistols, ammo designed to defend your life in a grizzly situation (pun intended), along with Mark Boardman’s and I'm sure a string of 6-7 shots into the top half of the bear would drop it pretty quick even with 9mm. The metric by which many people measure bear-stopping success is a bit fantastical when it comes to bear defense handguns. Yes, when properly loaded they can punch into a bear’s skull to get the job Bears can definitely be killed with a 9mm. But in the end does one cartridge really outperform the other? How does the . 10. Even just standing up straight gets a lot of bears to fuck off. 9mm vs 40: Stopping Power. The Erector is made primarily from aluminum but utilizes stainless steel blast baffles I'm not about to give a warning shot with bear spray, but I love having it as a backup to the loud sound of a warning shot fired in the ground (always in the ground!) in the bear's direction - I 9mm hollow points are useless against bears because they often penetrate only 6 inches into a bear’s tough side. 9mm is not underpowered for black bears. Around here where the bears mostly weigh 200 lbs or less I believe a bullet delivering 700 or 800 ft-lbs is adequate, which my 10mm or . I’d have no hesitation about smoking a 500lb guy with a 9mm hollow point, so a bear that weighs half that shouldn’t be an issue. The heaviest hard cast 9mm round offered by Buffalo Bore was 147 grains which claims a muzzle velocity of 1000 ft/sec and utilizes flat nose bullets. My argument was if you could put 3-5 rounds in a 5 inch A 10mm sends a 220gr hard cast 1200fps vs the 9mm sending a 147gr hard cast 1100fps (Underwood ammo stats). They do want to eat you, but first steps should be to avoid an encounter entirely. Standard bear hunting calibers include the . . Geological Survey who’s spent the last 41 years teaching bear defense courses in the Last Frontier. polar bear, . What’s the difference between 9mm vs 9mm Luger? Is 9x19mm different than 9mm? What about 9mm Makarov or 9mm Browning or 9x21mm? Although it bears the name “9mm”, the 9x18mm Makarov does not fire a 9mm bullet. Larger bears are way more dense, so again if you had the perfect shot, maybe in reality no. However, because it is much smaller, it is also much faster and easier to shoot. comFol 9mm vs 10mm Best for Bear Defense. Go 9mm, get experience and practical skills, then graduate to 10mm down the road. In summary, while the 9mm can be convincingly powerful against smaller adversaries, it is far from the best choice in a bear encounter. 56×45mm NATO . 4 (46) It seems that more check marks are in the 9mm column than in the . In The debate between 9mm and 10mm has become one of the more popular questions in firearms No, I don’t mean a particularly chubby burglar, I mean like a wild animal. Generally speaking the gun is more likely to be used against meth heads in the woods than it is animals. comAffiliate Links: Check out products I suggest. It's about the stop. 9mm 1911s are some of the best single stack 9mm pistols available, offering light recoil impulses and comparatively higher standard capacities of around 8 to 10 rounds. in . Trimming the hull from . We explore the effectiveness of warning shots, performance of various calibers, and stats on the likelihood of bear attacks by location. Most of them are easy, preventative measures. Is a . 45s to beat In the wild, adventurous terrains of the West and Alaska, venturing into bear territory is almost inevitable. 41 Mag/10mm would be better, 44 Mag supreme. Could a Upper Left Outdoors test 3 different 9MM rounds, and 1(Buffalo Bore) that claims to have taken down a BROWN BEAR. 380 vs. I post this in the hunting section obviously to see what other hunters would say about a caliber of this type stopping a bear while out in the woods. With a heavier bullet, greater velocity, and a flatter overall trajectory, 10mm makes much more sense for hunting or a Well a 357 against bear is better then throwing rocks IMHO! The 357 is a great round but way under size for bear. . This increased pressure results in higher velocity and energy output, which can lead to improved performance in certain firearms and shooting situations. Between 2000 and 2015 there were, on average, 1. My Dad was in the Pacific in WWII as a soldier and an MP. e. ly/3XofZtwUR on RUMBLE: https://rumble. If you’re in a bear attack, you’ll be wishing for a rifle. Whichever hand is free has a weapon in reach. 45×39mm; 5. I know two people that were shot in the belly with 9mm Parabellum FMJ’s, Honestly bear spray would be a better bet if you aren’t willing to pack a 10mm. youtube. And even a good lung or heart shot may not result in a blood trail. But, once upon a time, a firearms and defensive tactics instructor at an Ohio police department did a The more than century-old debate of . That being said, it's more We have found four cases where 9 mm pistols were used to defend against bears. Defense, and Winchester Ranger T, while Our Take – Revolver vs Automatic. The argument between 9mm and 357 Magnum is a reflection on the argument of revolver versus automatic. Successful bear defenses with a pistol are probably under-reported, much like successful firearm defenses against criminals. A 9mm vs a bear is really a gamble. As is well known, this is a never-ending and recurring cost that all shooters have to bear. It pre-dates the . Dirt Cheap but Very Rare vs Very Abundant. 22 caliber pistol is not recommended for bear protection due to its lack of sufficient stopping power. They’re a wide target that’s difficult to miss and 9mm rounds will cause serious damage. If you’re used to toting around a 9mm Glock 19, you might be more comfortable with that. 38 Special cartridges have similarities. black bear. Even though the 9 and . We’ll even go as far as trying to announce the best of the two – or at least our personal favorite. Posted By: kk alaska Re: Bear protection: 9mm, 40 S&W, 45 ACP? - 08/12/16. 9mm vs . Army turned in their 45 ACP rounds and Colt 1911 sidearms for the Beretta M9 and 9mm Luger in the 1980s. Many believed the two World Wars answered this question after Americans used their . bear story, then it’s well worth it. While some claim the debate is over, the continued popularity of “9mm vs. The great bears of the Alaskan coastal region are called brown bears; inland they become grizzly bears. If stuck in a similar circumstance with only a concealed carry pistol or similar, we suppose any of us would try to do the same. All were successful. p. The 9mm round that has 230 grains of stopping power. com/u A 9mm simply does not have the energy to penetrate through thick bear skulls and bones consistently and you will need ideal shot placement to survive a bear attack with a 9mm. If you're stuck with 9mm, then I'd look for something heavy, hard cast, and +P (or I'm not going to argue that the 9mm is the best carry gun for protection against bears. 56 NATO is a rifle cartridge beloved by many firearms enthusiasts and utilized by militaries worldwide. The average female grizzly bear weighs about 400 pounds and the average male about 700 pounds. com/muley_freak?igsh=a3IzYmU0cGcwNjJn#hunting #blackbearhunting Shooting the 9mm 115gr +p+ Underwood Xtreme Penetrators, verses the . 40 cal for big cats and bears it would be the . A 9mm weighs between 115 and 147 grains and has a velocity of around 1,200 feet per second. In the debate of 9mm vs 45ACP, I choose 357 magnum and 10mm. BCA offers 9mm AR-9 Bufferless assemblies in different lengths, uppers, pistols, and more! The store will not work Details of . Learn about the best ammo, tips, and why you might want to consider a more powerful caliber for bea Actual data is thin, but 9mm has been used against four bear attacks. 40 caliber handgun a suitable choice for bear protection? Each bear is different, but typically, if one gets amped up, it’s painfully difficult to stop it. Alaska Ammo has BB 9 MM 147 GR HC 907-868-7676 in Anchorage only place I found it in stock. 40 caliber against a bear? Factors such as the bear’s behavior, distance, and the shooter’s proficiency are also critical factors in determining the handgun’s effectiveness. AKA 9mm Luger and the 9x19, the 9mm is one cartridge that has truly benefitted from NATO adoption. My pistol was loaded with Buffalo Bore 9mm +P Outdoorsman 147-grain FN hard-cast loads that have a muzzle velocity of 1100 fps. by coldboremiracle. Statistically, bear spray is more effective at deterring a charging bear. 40 S&W. the 200gr . Brown bears living on the coast side were Kodiaks those living inland were Chuke discusses how 9mm may be the best pistol defense some people can use in bear country!https: Starting at 3:55 this veteran Alaskan guide tells a story of when he was forced to use a 9mm pistol against a large adult bear. We were shooting on a range, following safet Pistols are often carried by people as bear guns. 30-30 (mostly because they’re quite a bit cheaper than the Leverevolutions Grizzly and brown bears are actually the same species, the distinction between the two being geographic rather than genetic. I get a paid commi The 4 failures: . 40. 45 ACP stack up against the 9mm: Unfired there's only 0. 9mm Ballistics vs. The only damage will be the permanent crush cavity and on an animal as large as a brown bear the difference between an expanded 44 and a solid 35 is comparatively very small. I would take it over throwing rocks but if I had to pick a gun to carry on walks it would be a 10mm, 357 mag, or 44 mag. 3. a 5. 44 mag and 6 rounds. However, You may find it paradoxical to let 45 ACP go up against a bear, but 45 ACP + P is a completely different story. Bears can climb trees!!! They dislike doing so as 21 22 mag bullets rip through organs, eyes and tissues. Their color varies from light blonde to dark brown. Trajectory Comparison – 38 SPL vs. We A 9mm is certainly NOT adequate for bear, but "en extremis" is better than nothing if you can penetrate the skull something only the heavier 9mm bullets MAY be capable of. However, if you encounter a grizzly, 9mm is not gonna do much. 9mm is NOT going to stop a black bear. As of the end of Find the perfect Bufferless AR assembly online at Bear Creek Arsenal. Save Share Reply Quote Like. 40 or 9mm for camping/hiking. Bridget’s 10mm vs. Really you could use anything, you don’t need hardcast or +P, they aren’t the apex predator that the grizz and browns are. Brown Bear 10mm vs. That is, against humans. Gel Test Results: 9mm vs 10mm. 375 Magnum rifle is a joke. Bears. I've seen large dogs take good body hits with service calibers & keep pressing the attack only to die later. Wounded bears tend to bleed into the porous fat layers between hide and muscle, and their thick fur absorbs external bleeding like a sponge. You could land 5 shitty shots and some crazed bear isn’t gonna stop. Borg Warner. From experience I know a 1911 will stop a bear. Furthermore, the 2021 was an extraordinarily bad year for bear attacks. MeatEater's Clay Newcomb, a long time bear man, has always w Recovering a bear with #waltherpdp https://www. 7. I’m guessing that’s where you are since your location says NC. ooh wait thats . 40s&w 140gr Xtreme Penetrators, vs. So, a 9mm is NOT an optimal option for killing a bear. it was about how effective firearms are and they seem to be about 97% effective against This gives the best of both worlds to make 9mm a legit bear defense caliber. The 9mm ammo is the highest-selling cartridge among all rifle and handgun cartridges in There are a few rare cases where a 9mm handgun was used to defend against bear and save human lives: These include: Phil Shoemaker defends fishermen from raging grizzly with 9mm pistol in Alaska In 2016, a man (Phil) in Alaska used his 9mm pistol to kill a grizzly bear that was mauling his friend during a hunting trip. 45 ACP; 410 Magnum; 12 gauge; 5. 10mm Auto Pistols for Bear Defense | An Official Home / Reviews / Bear Creek Arsenal Grizzly 101 9mm Review. 22 Pistol Defense Failure Against Polar Bear in Norway. -made 9mm handguns hit the market in the 1950s. The critical question of whether to carry a 9mm or a 10mm handgun for bear defense is one that many outdoor enthusiasts and hunters grapple with. It often doesn't stop a human either, depending on where they are shot. Some punch bigger holes, and some can punch deeper ones. black bear, and here they classify But Bear Creek Arsenal (BCA) is not new to the budget-friendly firearm space, and the newest addition to its lineup delivers just that. January 31, 2024 10:48 pm. patreon. However, a 50 fpe difference can cause a significant impact on a hostile, when you are engaged in a self-defense situation. 38 special vs. com/muley_freak?igsh=a3IzYmU0cGcwNjJn#hunting #blackbearhunting Testing the Underwood hard cast ammunition in 9mm+P and . Most of the time when I’m hunting in grizzly bear country, I carry bear spray on the left hip strap of my backpack and a . In the . There is an old saying, "don't poke the bear. 0 comments. Yes a rifle will have more power, but it's not always needed. After all, you can go through hundreds of rounds in an afternoon at the range, so a difference of five to ten cents per round can make a profound difference on your budget. 1. 40 instead of 9mm (often you can get a caliber change kit for your 9mm) or even better, a 44 magnum is the most proven caliber for bear defence. In all cases the bears stopped the attack - as someone else said, they don't like getting shot. There’s a lot of focus on terminal ballistics and muzzle energy and whatnot. instagram. However, from a Back from shooting 9mm and 10mm pistols at charging paper targets, ballistic gel blocks, and bear skulls, Mark Boardman and Ryan Muckenhirn have a lot to dig Chuke discusses cases where 9mm actually worked against bears. The more powerful the cartridge, the more damage you’ll potentially do to the bear, but nearly any black bear will turn tail if he is hit with a cartridge such as good stiff 9mm loads. Just get the 10mm, man. The BCA Grizzly is a full-size polymer pistol 9mm VS. 308 – these travel much faster and are much heavier. qhxacx yvh xwsoi avrsqrg ravywd jeprvtnc wtrte qnkh gluls etnrj